Way to go, NCAA. You did the right thing -- the surprising thing. Never before in history had more than two Ivy League teams made the NCAA Division I Women's Soccer Championships. On Sunday night, however, the selection committee announced that four Ivy squads -- Penn, Princeton, Dartmouth and league champ Harvard -- had earned bids for the 48-team field. Surprising? Yes. Deserving? Unquestionably. This season, 262 teams played Division I women's soccer. Twenty-three of those teams earned automatic spots in the Tournament by winning their respective conference championships, while a 24th made the cut through a two-conference play-in qualifier. Of the 24 at-large spots, the Ivies nabbed three of them -- three times the number of at-large bids that the Ancient Eight had ever received in the past. "I was a little surprised that we had four teams going, surprised in the sense that it's not the traditional thing," Penn coach Andy Nelson said. But times are changing in the world of women's soccer. With four teams in the field, the Ivy League outweighs seeming heavyweights the Big Ten (three teams), the Big East (three) and the SEC (two). The Ivies also hold their own with the likes of the Big 12 and Pac-10, both of which received four bids. In fact, only the venerable ACC (six) received more. Looking at the numbers, though, it's clear why the Ivy League's four invites are not so much a lucky aberration as a just reward. "When you look at the quality of the teams in the Ivy League, it's not so much of a surprise because there's a lot of good teams," Nelson said. "I think the Ivy League's developing very fast into one of the elite conferences in the country." Though Nelson is an Ivy League newcomer, there's no question about the league's ascent to the upper echelon of women's soccer conferences. The statistics speak for themselves. In the RPI ratings for the '98 season, released last February, the Ivy League ranked a surprising second. The eight Ivies went an impressive 60-22-6 in non-league play last year. This season, they were a solid 51-23-5. Most impressive, however, is that Dartmouth -- the fifth-place team in the league, behind Yale -- made the cut. At 9-7-2 overall and just 3-3-1 in the league, the Big Green are the only ones in the 48-team field with fewer than 10 wins. But the selection of Dartmouth, which entered the week ranked No. 24 in the NSCAA poll, barely raised eyebrows among the other Ivy coaches. After a slow start, the Big Green picked up steam, beating tournament-qualifier Hartford and losing 2-1 in overtime to current No. 13 Connecticut. They also took No. 3 North Carolina, a team with more national championships (14) than losses (12) in the past 19 seasons, to double overtime before dropping a 1-0 heartbreaker. The selection of the Big Green speaks both to the ascent of the Ivy League and the parity within the conference as well. Ivy League women's soccer is not men's basketball, where Penn and Princeton rule the roost and bottom-dwellers like Brown get pounded in-conference and blown away by non-league lightweights like Central Connecticut and Robert Morris. In the world of Ivy League women's soccer, however, there are no gimmes; every league contest is a battle. "If you look at the competition within the league, there are lots and lots of one-goal games every weekend, and anything can happen at any given day," said Harvard coach Tim Wheaton, whose team went 7-0 in league play but beat last-place Columbia by just a goal. Battle-tested in league play, the Ivy squads have taken to abusing opponents in non-league games in recent years. In '98, Penn struggled in conference play, earning their first Ivy win on the final day of the season to finish 1-5-1, tied for last in the league. Out of conference, however, the Quakers were a downright Carolinian 10-0. This year, Penn skyrocketed to 6-1 in the league, while Columbia plummeted to 0-6-1. The Lions, in turn, vented their Ivy frustrations against non-league opponents to the tune of an 8-1-1 out-of-conference record. This is hardly the same Ivy League that Wheaton entered in 1987. That season -- four years before Penn first fielded a team and nine years before the institution of automatic bids to the Tournament -- the Crimson went 3-1-2 in the Ivies, 8-2-3 overall. But neither Harvard nor Ivy champ Cornell received an NCAA invite. How about league parity? That season, Columbia scored just once in Ivy games while surrendering 26 goals. All things considered, the rise of Ivy League women's soccer may just make it the most impressive conference under the Ivy Group banner. True, in the world of heavyweight rowing, the Ivies have a near stranglehold on success, Cal and Washington aside. And the All-America squads for squash and fencing both read like Who's Who lists of the Ivy League. But soccer is a national sport, more mid-America and everywoman than Middlesex and Exeter. What about men's lacrosse, where Princeton has won five national titles in the '90s? How about wrestling, where the Quakers field a number of All-Americans and boast a top 10 ranking? Women's soccer has them both beat. Division I wrestling teams are outnumbered by women's soccer teams nearly 3-to-1 and political analysts rarely talk about Lacrosse Moms. Soccer is a sport played everywhere, but the seemingly old-money, East Coast, scholarship-lacking Ivies have risen to the ranks of the nation's best. But while crew may be a matter of staying atop the field until the scholarship powerhouses discover the sport and catch up, the Ivies show no sign that 1999 is the peak. "There's something to the idea that our institutions do have an attraction, and our teams have an attraction," said Jeff Orleans, Executive Director of the Ivy League. Orleans questioned the future of the Ivies in the burgeoning world of women's soccer when he was appointed in '84 but now has no doubts. "As long as it looks like a good experience and one where you're going to improve as you play, that keeps us competitive." And it's high time the NCAA took notice of the Ivies' rise. Two years ago, the committee rewarded the Ivy League with no at-large bids. League-champ Harvard responded by giving undefeated, eventual-champion North Carolina their toughest test of the tournament in a 1-0 loss. Two years later, the NCAA Women's Soccer Committee has finally dignified the legitimacy of the Ivies by peppering a 48-team pool in a truly national sport with a full 50 percent of the Ivy League. After thanking Harvard for making the league look good by rising to the top 10 and earning one of the eight seeds in the Tournament, Princeton coach Julie Shackford summed it up best: "I think the NCAA showed a lot of integrity in discerning that this is a legitimate league." So congratulations, selection committee. You've done well.
The Daily Pennsylvanian is an independent, student-run newspaper. Please consider making a donation to support the coverage that shapes the University. Your generosity ensures a future of strong journalism at Penn.
DonatePlease note All comments are eligible for publication in The Daily Pennsylvanian.
