Students balance ADHD, classwork
Some believe that a handful of students may abuse disability laws to gain special accommodations in school
· October 27, 2011, 10:23 pm
Every year, around 300 students at Penn are identified with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder by Student Disabilities Services.
But Disability Services Director Susan Shapiro suspects many more students suffer from the mental disorder.
Recently, ADHD diagnoses have increased substantially in the United States, rising an average of 5.5 percent per year from 2003 to 2007, according to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention.
One factor leading to this rise in diagnoses may be that students abuse disability law to gain special accommodations, The New York Times reported two weeks ago, pointing out that parents may push for their children to get diagnoses.
At Penn, SDS is committed to “maintaining the academic integrity” of the University by only providing accommodations to students who truly need it, Shapiro said.
To determine reasonable accommodations for students, a committee reads the student’s history of treatment, Shapiro said, adding that approving accommodations — from extended time on tests to taking tests in smaller rooms — is “not a simple process.”
“Often standards are different in high schools,” Shapiro explained, adding that Penn denies students seeking accommodations every year.
Students at Penn who suffer from ADHD have mixed feelings about medication and special accommodations.
A College sophomore, who wished to remain anonymous because she did not want to make her medical issues public, felt that Adderall, the drug typically prescribed to ADHD patients to improve concentration, “helped so much for the SATs.”
Although she believes it is “kind of sick and unfair” for some students to get this advantage, she said there isn’t a cut and dry way to determine whether an ADHD patient should be prescribed a drug.
“A lot of people would focus more from [the medication] even though it’s wrong and could be abused,” she added.
Other students who are diagnosed with ADHD do not feel that the medication gives them an advantage.
“It made me tired,” said a College junior, who also wished to remain anonymous for personal reasons. Although he had been taking Adderall since second grade, he stopped taking the medication when he came to Penn because its side effects made it difficult for him to stay awake.
However, without medication, he has a hard time focusing and taking notes during class.
“I feel like sometimes I’m wasting my time going to lectures,” the student said. “It’s frustrating because I pay so much to come here.”
He compensates by doing all the readings and sharing notes with classmates.
“It can be an advantage. I have a lot of energy,” he said.
He feels the actions of students who fake ADHD symptoms to get extra time on tests is “total garbage,” adding that students “have to learn to make do with the limitations they have.”
Both students have gravitated towards the humanities, which Shapiro says is common for students with ADHD, who may find writing papers easier than taking tests.
In high school, “I made a lot of math mistakes,” the College sophomore said. “When I started using Adderall, I could do math tests without a lot of mistakes.”
Studying humanities is “significantly easier for me,” the College junior agreed. “If I don’t pay attention in an English class, I can still read the book,” whereas if he gets distracted during math lectures, it is hard to make up the material.
Faculty members are required by law to accommodate their students with ADHD.
“Once we hear the accommodation from SDS, we always accommodate it,” Math Undergraduate Chairman Robin Pemantle wrote in an email. “It’s not just a good idea, it’s the law.”




Comments (1)
Misconceptions about ADD/ADHD
October 28, 2011, 7:04 am
Flag this comment
Adderall is not an “advantage” for people with ADD. For those who don’t have ADD, adderall (amphetimine) is a powerful stimulant that keeps us awake all night. Non-ADD people take it so that they can stay up and cram for tests. Whether that’s smart I leave to the sleep specialists. For those with ADD or ADHD, on the other hand, Adderall has a calming effect, even making one feel fatigued, as the student in the article notes. So that’s one sign as to whether you have ADD or not.
There’s also a difference between ADD and ADHD People with ADD can be highly focused—to their detriment. So one misconception in this article is that ADD people can’t do math. Quite the contrary: some of the greatest innovators in math and science are thought to have had ADD. It’s the stereotype, in fact, of the absent-minded professor. ADD people get so caught up in what they’re doing they forget to comb their hair, turn in assignments, etc. They are also typically able to see patterns across a wide range of disparate ideas, which is what leads them to be innovative. It also makes it tough for them to survive in a conventional academic environment. So if you find yourself forgetting to turn in assignments, show up for things, lose track of class discussions because you’re still thinking, complexly, about a point brought up, have difficulty with reading comprehension but can analyze the hell out of a piece of writing, have trouble organizing your writing but have great ideas and evidence, you should get checked out for ADD. Adderall will change your life.
If you have ADHD, your challenge is greater because the “H” basically means hyperactive, so without the Adderall you tend to be fidgety and that, in combination with the ADD, and that can affect your concentration.
People with ADD and ADHD are often called lazy, undisciplined, disorganized, forgetful—and people tell them to get organizers, etc., but those don’t really help. If you think you have ADD or ADHD, go get an assessment. If you have a smart student (as most are at Penn) and s/he seems to miss a lot of assignments, or not write as well as s/he speaks, you might suggest that she get an assessment. I think you can do this at Weingarten but I’m not sure.
Comments are closed for this item.