Author dispels same-sex marriage myths
· March 19, 2010, 4:00 am
Martha Nussbaum discusses “Same-Sex Marriage: Beyond the Politics of Disgust” at the 2010 Levin Family Dean’s Forum: A Celebration of Intellectual Excellence.
When Martha Nussbaum took the stage, she tried to define the elusive term, “the politics of disgust.”
“We can’t make policies based on disgust. We have to make policies based on more than that because disgust only leads to hate,” she said, speaking to 495 students, faculty and parents of all ages, backgrounds and sexuality in Zellerbach Theater last night about the same-sex marriage rights issue in America.
But it seemed like she was talking about more.
Nussbaum, professor of law and ethics at the University of Chicago and author of her most recent book, From Disgust to Humanity: Sexual Orientation and Constitutional Law, began her lecture by discussing types of couples whose marriages the American society approves of.
She praised the political and social progress Americans have made in the past decade, concerning same-sex marriage rights. However, she stressed more progress must be made in the future.
Each year, the Levin Family Dean’s Forum, host of last night’s event, invites a nationally recognized scholar in the liberal arts field to speak. The forum has been celebrating the arts and sciences for over two decades.
“The forum is an opportunity for the School of Arts and Sciences dean to spotlight contributions of experts,” said Loraine Boehmcke, director of public relations in the School of Arts and Sciences and organizer of the lecture. “It’s also an opportunity to highlight excellence in arts and sciences by students at the University.”
The event began by honoring 10 undergraduates and 10 graduates from different liberal arts programs for their academic achievements in the College of Arts and Sciences.
During her lecture, Nussbaum recognized the religious and public arguments against same-sex marriage, and she questioned whether or not dissenters are discussing the issue in “a neutral language or a textual and doctrinal language.”
She emphasized how religious arguments against same-sex marriage should not serve as blanket policy for all Americans outside of the religion’s denomination. She compared these current religious arguments to a hypothetical situation in which Jews prohibit all Americans from eating pork.
Nussbaum then addressed the public arguments against same-sex marriage. She dispelled arguments that same-sex marriages could not practice procreation because the state cannot and does not limit marriage status to couples that plan to and do have children.
She continued by addressing the argument that same-sex marriages would strain the tradition of marriage. Nussbaum argued the tradition of marriage is not and will not be sullied by same-sex marriages because such assumption is rooted in myth.
Nussbaum concluded her lecture by highlighting that the right for marriage must be “offered with even hand” because it’s unconstitutional “to fence certain groups out of constitutional rights.”
Finally, Nussbaum opened the floor to questions from students and other audience members.
“I hope the lecture and the event helps students engage with the speaker and the subject,” Boehmcke said. “It’s great to see students inspired by this type of interaction, and we hope they leave today with a desire to further pursue their liberal arts passions.”
Recipient of one of the 2010 Dean’s Scholars awards and College senior Luv Patel said he was very much interested in the lecture. “I better understand now how policy makers really can’t use disgust as political reasoning,” he said. “Nussbaum made that very clear.”





Comments (6)
lordme
June 6, 2010, 9:40 am
Flag this comment
I am always searching for quality content. Thanks
|
bobmarks
June 15, 2010, 4:15 am
Flag this comment
same sex marriages are wrong, it doesnt matter how many discussion ocur its wrong period.
daily sudoku puzzles
john100
July 5, 2010, 12:45 am
Flag this comment
Argentina Soccer Association) to create a high-tech deterrent to soccer thugs that will include biometric scanners and electronic cards with personal information as a requirement to attend a occer match. According to the Reuter’s translation of the AFA's proposal, "Anyone who wants to go to a soccer stadium must be registered on a database and possess a magnetic card which includes their name, photo, document number, and fingerprints." The article also points out that, given the crumbling state of many Argentine soccer stadiums, it's hard to imagine their implementing such a high-tech solution with any efficacy.
john100
July 7, 2010, 12:18 am
Flag this comment
The Indians are positive people they look at life with the outlook that they are one with the ground and love all that the earth consist of because they feel that it is a part of them becasue it has been with them since the beginning of time. Americans just look at the world as a place that we live and take in all of its resources with out even a thanks to where it came from. Indians and Americans are bothe different racess of people who think in terms of the long term goal of personal enlightenment with the world and other human beings. The Native Americans are perfect role models for what an ideal shoule do in life and how one should behave towards the world because indians are natural people who believe in the inner good of all living and non living object. This just proves the point about how for Americans can be willing to go to be one with the earth as Native Americans have come to be. Surely it has taken many years to take on this position of being one with the spiritual earth and physical earth becasue this is not just somthing that comes over night. The all knowing subject is one that comes through age and wisdom is stored through age along with the love of all things. Earth is a place to be loved and shared with everyone.
lbm0914
July 9, 2010, 4:27 am
Flag this comment
I hope the pitchblack diehards can come to realise it's now springtime before issue the warning on behalf of fashion with this , my . Look what is under the arm of ? A Chanel Woven Fabric tote. Springtime feelings, springtime handbags. Babe, don't be dragged by the winter fashion, just a touch at the fab can light you up and push you towards the vibrant spring.
kimchanir
July 19, 2010, 3:09 am
Flag this comment
such forums can help some people in developing their future stuff and stay on their own legs more
Comments are closed for this item.