Editorial | Controlling chatter

The ban on cell phones while driving could have combated a huge problem

· April 24, 2009, 5:00 am

Share This

On Wednesday, the Pennsylvania House of Representatives unfortunately rejected a measure that would ban hand-held cell-phone use while driving in the state of Pennsylvania.

While the measure was harsh - it made talking on a hands-held phone a primary offense, meaning violators could be fined steeply - it was heading in the right direction and would have made a strong impact. Distracted driving causes many accidents, while it can easily be avoided, and for those reasons it's increasingly becoming the focus of lawmakers. In Philadelphia, a ban even stricter than the proposed state law was passed unanimously last week by the City Council, which the mayor intends to sign next week.

While banning hand-held cell-phone use seems harsh to twenty-somethings who have mastered the art of texting on a treadmill, one only needs to spend five minutes on Locust to see dozens of students concentrate more on what they're typing than where they're walking. The ban in Philadelphia even includes pedestrians, skaters and cyclists. These measures make sense given the relative sate of congestion in Philadelphia traffic.

The sentiment of the Pennsylvania bill lives on in the form of a second bill. This one seeks to impose less-harsh penalties on those caught driving and engaging in a range of distracting behaviors, from putting on makeup to reading to, yes, talking on a hand-held cell phone. Hopefully this will be enough to get people thinking twice before they let go of the wheel to pick up the phone.

Comments (1)

It'd be a start, but...

December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm

Flag this comment

It's the distraction caused by the conversation on and dialing of a cellphone that leads to problems, so allowing hands-free to be legal is a little superfluous. If you're going to ban cell phones while driving you also have to consider things like: Radios Passengers (yes, they contribute to the number of accidents, see links below) Food/beverage use Driving with one hand Speeding and driving too slow Driving while being tired Site-seeing and accident watching Is using your cellphone an increase distraction while driving? Absolutely, but it's amazing that people demand for certain things that cause distractions, but not others. It's ignorant and naive to point to one thing (in this case: using cell phones while driving) and saying that it would be life changing. Then again, common sense has seemingly gone out the window. http://www.sixwise.com/newsletters/05/07/20/the-6-most-common-causes-of-automobile-crashes.htm http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/n/a/2006/04/21/national/a055331D55.DTL

Comments are closed for this item.