Callum Makkai | Residences for the rest of us
Penn has ignored the housing needs of graduate and professional students, but eastward expansion plans may offer a solution
· November 13, 2008, 5:00 am
The jet zoomed past the shiny skyscrapers and over the Delaware River, revealing an awesome panorama. As the plane touched down on the tarmac, a palpable sense of elation overtook my weary soul. It was a relief to have the long journey from Beijing behind me.
From the airport shuttle, I peered out the window as the vehicle weaved back and forth through streets of ramshackle row homes. It was early morning when I arrived at last. Pounding up a gloomy stairwell to my temporary lodging, I sat back on a sunken bed and surveyed the decrepit room, strewn with a stranger's unwanted junk.
That's when my buoyant mood evaporated, and I knew I'd made a hard landing in the City of Brotherly Love.
The lack of temporary housing in West Philly is an unfortunate reality for new arrivals to Penn's graduate and professional programs. "There's a need for transitional space, especially for international students and for students that are coming from far away," said Nikki Thorpe, vice chairwoman of Student Life for the Graduate and Professional Student Assembly. "In many cases these students decide to live in Sansom and grow increasingly frustrated when they realize there is more affordable and perhaps higher-quality housing elsewhere."
Sansom Place is Penn's attempt at graduate-student housing. According to GAPSA, the two towers offer about 700 beds for a mere 6.7 percent of our graduate students. Compare these facilities to a school like MIT, which houses a third of its graduate population on campus in five residences for single students and two buildings for those with spouses or families.
Penn has a double standard when it comes to housing. On one hand, the University seems happy to erect on-campus accommodations for undergraduates, but for everybody else, it looks to the private sector to develop options in the surrounding community.
Often these projects involve the University leasing land to a firm that then develops a mixed-use facility like Domus at 34th and Chestnut streets. "What the University is gaining is the ability to build all these buildings very quickly all at once," said Andrew Rennekamp, GAPSA's chairman. "We have different types of land leases, but it's still a very narrow, land-lease focused agenda."
These high-end units are nice, but they're just too expensive for many struggling students.
That's because while Penn has transformed itself into an educational juggernaut, it has taken the neighborhood with it. Local rental rates are rapidly increasing, and graduate students have to move farther and farther away from campus - either eastward or westward - in search of affordable housing.
The result has been a split between those who live in West Philly and those who prefer the amenities of Center City. And there are two ways of looking at Penn's position in this evolving urban geography. Either it divides us or unites us.
As things stand, some graduate students feel they're missing out on the Penn experience because of the dearth of dedicated space for them. "We are hearing that in some cases they feel pretty isolated from the Penn community," said Thorpe. "They want to be united across different disciplines, and they see an opportunity for that in their housing situation."
Penn Connects, the University's ambitious plan to develop its newly acquired land along the Schuylkill River, offers one means of redress. "It's a huge opportunity for the University to expand graduate student housing," Rennekamp told me.
Unfortunately, the University seems to be ignoring graduate students yet again; its plans for a new College House on Hill Field targets undergrads. Penn simply can't afford to pass up this rare chance to build a deeper sense of community among the graduate and professional student population.
A multifunctional living space near the beautiful Schuylkill River for graduate students and visitors? Now that would really help connect Penn graduate students - to each other and to the world.
Callum Makkai is a 2nd year doctoral student in the School of Arts and Sciences, from Halifax, Canada. His e-mail is makkai@dailypennsylvanian.com. Moment of Clarity appears on alternating Thursdays.




Comments (5)
Current Grad Student & Alum
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
The last housing built by Penn for undergraduates and graduate students was built in 1970/71...the high rises and graduate towers. The vast majority of graduate students are uninterested and even unwilling to live amongst throngs of undergrads. Each program has the responsibility and resources to help their students, domestic and international, locate suitable temporary and permanent lodging. Your lack of preparedness for Penn is not the university's fault.
Undergrad Alum and Current Grad Student
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
Baby, we're graduate students. If we don't know how to research where we might want to live while working on advanced degrees in this glorious little town of ours, we deserve to end up in the grey hell of Sansom. I understand the need for a short-term space for international students who might not be comfortable navigating craigslist or any of the city's real estate guides. They need a week or two to find a cozy spot in a retrofitted mansion in West Philly. But seriously, the rest of us? If we can isolate genes, draw parallels between Christopher Marlowe & Tony Kushner, and translate cuneiform tablets, we don't need the school holding our hand while we whine about twin, extra-long beds. Let Penn spend buckets of cash on something useful. We don't need to be coddled.
reality check
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
This is a good opinion piece because I think it highlights one of the major drawbacks of attending Penn: lack of affordable, comfortable, on-campus housing. I also think this piece could have been improved with some more research and facts. Penn hasn't constructed any new dorms in over 30 years because it hasn't had the money to build anything. Although our overall endowment is ranked ninth, that doesn't take into account how many students we have. Our endowment per student was ranked 71st in 2006, putting us in league with Kalamazoo College and the University of Kansas. The construction industry in Philadelphia is dominated by union, making cost of construction higher than elsewhere. Leasing land to developers is a short-term solution for the housing problem. In the future when the university has more money, it will be in a position to buy back the leases for those buildings, demolish them and erect something more permanent. Furthermore, Penn has drawn up detained plans for the postal property which are available on the internet. Despite the small size of the postal property, the fact that it is bisected by a subway line, freight train, Amtrak, multiple utilities, and is cut off from the river by a freeway, Penn has managed to squeeze a mixed use tower on walnut street for graduate student housing and a hotel.
Alum
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
Not that Mr. Makkai doesn't make a good point but no new college houses have been built for undergraduates in recent memory and only 1 is planned as part of the campus expansion so the double standard is not really as prevalent as Mr. Makkai suggests. Many undegraduates are forced to live off campus as well and in hideously ugly buildings like the Radian.
nike air max
July 13, 2010, 2:56 am
Flag this comment
when you join some pratices you need a good equitment.One such shoe is the Tailwind.As you can see the Tailwind is a shoe that has the runner in mind. is one of the most famous and well-received Nike shoes series, and it also is the first which applied with air cushion.
With a long history of marketing, Nike Company has released a series of new stylish shoes like,, shoes, Force one shoes and so on.
Team Trust II Men's Basketball Shoe - A true team player, the Team Trust II Men's Basketball Shoe has optimal traction and maximum support to make the most out of your footwork.
A point of historical interest about the is that it was originally known as the Plus,though almost nobody in the know refers to them as such these days.For more information about TN, please contact with us.
The departing underclassmen were the core of a team that went 35-3 and won the Southeastern Conference tournament before advancing to the regional finals of the NCAA tournament."I think that's what entices a lot of players with that situation," Knight said.
Comments are closed for this item.