Another new design for the bridge, from the community
South Street Bridge Coalition proposes plan geared at improving bridge for bikers, pedestrians
· April 11, 2008, 5:00 am
After much delay, the South Street Bridge Replacement Project finally appears poised to begin - but community members are still trying to assert their views about the project.
Community members have been critical of the design put forth by the city, and last month the South Street Bridge Coalition commissioned urban planning firm Wallace Roberts & Todd L.L.C. to propose design modifications to the bridge.
The 69-page report was released last Friday.
"The object here is to spark a full and complete dialogue between all of the stakeholders on what we ultimately want for the bridge," said coalition organizer James Campbell.
While community members are excited that the project will begin soon, they say the city has not included their input in the design process.
City officials could not be reached for comment for this article.
The current design from the city Streets Department, which would take about 20 months and $54 million to complete, calls for an expansion of the two-lane bridge into five lanes, to help increase speeds on the bridge and reduce traffic buildup.
The plan also calls for a 5-foot bike lane and 9-foot sidewalks along the main part of the bridge.
The new report includes a list of 23 recommendations for changes in the plan. The suggestions include the removal of the fifth traffic lane, along with the enclosed overlook towers, which some critics feared may have become easy mugging spots and are not visually appealing.
One of the major concerns of the community was making the bridge more accessible to pedestrians and cyclists. Because the current bridge design has no barrier between the sidewalk and automotive traffic, many are concerned that the city plans to construct a bridge that is focused primarily on the concerns of the motorist.
One major suggestion in the proposal would combat this by moving the crash barrier between the bicycle lane and car lanes, as well as widening bike lanes and sidewalks, something that could be done if the fifth traffic lane is removed, and affordable if the overlook towers are abandoned.
The actions of the South Street Bridge Coalition have been supported by some of the most powerful people in the city and state, including Mayor Nutter and Governor Rendell.
Penn officials are still reviewing the suggestions at the request of the South Street Bridge Coalition.
The coalition wants Penn to support the plan.
But, according to Facilities spokesman Tony Sorrentino, "Penn has no authority here in ratifying or reviewing these plans."
Sorrentino added that Penn supports a bridge that balances safety and speed of completion.




Comments (1)
Jim Campbell
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
Dan, Thank you for your article. However, you got some things right and some things wrong. As was pointed out to you, the Coalition consists of not just community but major community associations, the Bicycle Coalition, and other interested organizations and institutions. So, not only have community members been critical of the present design but so have many of the above Coalition members. What was said to you was that in 2001 the communities were told that it was too early to respond to the proposed design and then when shown the design in 2007 were told that it was too late. It was not until last year that the greater community was shown the final design, and when shown this ?final? design decided that it had to take action. Please note that what we have called the Community Design also increases the number of lanes on the Bridge to reduce traffic congestion. However, we believe it does reduction in a way that simply does not make the Bridge into a high speed highway bridge. The community wants a safe and friendly bridge for all modes of transportation from University City to Center City Ð not just a slingshot to and from the expressway. The Community Design contains numerous design suggestions to make what we believe to be a greener, more pedestrian and bike friendly bridge while not penalizing the motorist. We told you that the response to these efforts at the local, state, and federal levels has generally been well received. Remember we discussed the change in Federal policy that now requires a ?balanced solution for all travel modes?. However, we also said that the report has been given to Mayor Nutter and that we understand that he is reviewing the suggestions. Once the Mayor has made up his mind if some or all of the suggestions are good, we assume that he will then ask the Governor for state support. Assuming that the Governor then agrees with the Mayor, all of us will need to go to the Federal Government for their support. Together we can have a better Bridge but cannot do so without everyone joining in. It is our understanding that Penn has been reviewing the Bridge design and has made periodic comments including supporting bike lanes and wider sidewalks. Now, we all need to get it right. Getting changes is all about philosophy, process, details, and political will. We asked you to review the report in detail and review what other reporters had said about the Bridge. Jim Campbell for the South Street Bridge Coalition
Comments are closed for this item.