Sharon Udasin | Penn should be spreading the word on flu vaccine
With college life such a great environment for diseases to spread, the
· November 6, 2006, 5:00 am
Senior guard Ibrahim Jaaber winces after tweaking his ankle against Villanova. Penn has relied heavily on its starters so far.
T hree years ago, my hall in the Upper Quadrangle was the victim of an unrepentant attack.
One by one, my friends and I fell - to the hands of a vicious, cackling microbe, most formally known as the influenza virus.
We successively came down with 102-degree fevers and overall respiratory incapacitation. The quaint and mazelike design of the quad may be an ideal setting for secret pre-gaming, yet this claustrophobic environment is also the perfect harbor for an epidemic. And so the flu ran rampant.
Due to the risk factors associated with the vaccine, it would be ridiculous to suggest mandatory immunization across campus. If the treatment were scientifically flawless, such a requirement might be ideal, yet reality stands. We do not have the power to defeat this biological enemy, but we can hope to control its marauding schemes.
As The Daily Pennsylvanian reported on Oct. 19, there is no vaccination shortage this year, and students can make appointments to get shots or nasal sprays for only $25. Yet the University is doing an awful job advertising the vaccine's current availability. Aside from a few posted flyers inside Student Health, administrators have shamefully neglected their responsibilities to educate our student body. Penn should be doing all that it can to protect its community's health, and the first step would be to make people aware of their options - before that hellish fever begins.
"I saw the sign when I was already at Student Health, but that didn't help me because I was already sick," College junior Jessica Turner said.
Even the Office of Health Education's Web site is unhelpful, with outdated instructions from 2005 and paragraphs about an unrelated vaccine appearing under the link to flu information. If you click on the bolded terms that explain the two flu vaccines, all you'll see is an error message.
Director of Health Education Susan Villari assured me that her office has sent flyers to graduate student-health liaisons living in dormitories. Apparently, these students have not done their share of photocopying.
According to Student Health Director Evelyn Wiener, "Vaccination is the most effective way of prevention." However, the vaccine remains only about an 80- to 90-percent effective form of protection against flu contraction, Wiener said. So even if you have gotten the shot, don't plunge yourself headfirst into a steaming pile of influenza germs. And remember that you will still have no protection against the common cold, strep throat and other common winter illnesses.
"Side affects are usually mild: soreness at the injection site, aches, occasionally fever," Wiener said. "Life-threatening allergic reactions are rare."
Realizing the potential - but realistically minimal - risks of the flu vaccine, we might seek out some alternative methods of prevention. However, hand sanitizers and pre-emptive medications just won't cut it.
"Anti-viral medications such as Tamiflu can be used to prevent flu in someone who has been exposed, but it is usually used for a single exposure," Wiener said. "It is usually not recommended as a preventive method for the entire flu season."
Ultimately, there is just no substitute for the vaccine. Tight residential quarters and overly cozy relations among dorm residents provide the perfect catalyst for influenza to spread. Equally important, Penn students who work with young children should be immunized before entering neighborhood schools.
Although mandatory immunization would not be feasible, "if there were a severe outbreak, we would encourage vaccination of all populations," Wiener said.
Through some simple publicity, the Penn administration needs to encourage all students and staff to seek immunization. A few more flyers and even a PennPortal announcement about the vaccine's availability would require little effort. One month from now, instead of wheezing and shivering, vaccinated students will be healthy as can be.
Sharon Udasin is a College senior from East Brunswick, N.J. Her e-mail address is udasin@dailypennsylvanian.com. Shed a Little Light appears on Mondays.





Comments (4)
Sharon Udasin
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
Now that the columnists are allowed to reply to their own column comments, I would like to clarify something. As of last week, when I wrote this opinion, the website was not at all updated, as I described. There was no huge link to the flu shot on the OHE home page, and under flu heading, there was irrelevant information about another vaccine, error messages and a time stamp of approximately one year ago. The page entitled "Where can you get the Flu Shot" (http://www.vpul.upenn.edu/ohe/library/cold/flu-shot.htm) now features entirely new data, posted within the past couple of days. The only reason why these additions were made was because I contacted Susan Villari last week to notify her that the Web site was obsolete. When I spoke to her, she had no idea that the currently published information was not correct and up-to-date. She must have requested an expedient revamping of the site when she heard that this column was being written, and it would have been nice of her to let me know that she chose to do so. Thanks for reading. -Sharon
Phil Simms, MD
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
Not only should the vaccine be better publicized, it should also be offered free of charge, both to students, as well as faculty, staff, and other Penn employees, as do most major corporations for their employees. In the long run, such an approach would probably save the university money. By greatly reducing the number university employees affected by the flu, absenteeism from work, be it by faculty, staff, maintenance workers, etc., could be greatly reduced. Absenteeism is a major expense for any employer. In addition, the greater the number of people in the Penn community immunized, the lower the risk to all, through the phenomenon of "herd immunity," referring to the fact that if a large percentage of the community is immunized, those not immunized are also protected (fewer around to spread the disease to the unimmunized).
Dan Kresnek
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
Hmmm, the OHE website IS updated, I saw flyers in my hall about the flu shot and is there anyone that doens't know they can go to any doctor (or Student Health) to get a shot? It's a no brainer. Do students need to be lead by the hand and shown what to do? I think we are smart enough to figure it out without having the University shower us with emails and flyers and post cards. Stop whining and just go get a shot!
Duh
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
And it never occurred to you to recheck the website the day before you printed this column? Please...
Comments are closed for this item.