Study finds most University faculty hold liberal views
· September 12, 2003, 5:00 am
Is it possible for a conservative student or doctoral candidate to take a class with a like-minded professor?
A new study released by the Center for the Study of Popular Culture suggests that it may not be.
"Most students probably graduate without ever having a class taught by a conservative professor," wrote CSPR President and well-known conservative David Horowitz in the project's executive summary.
The study -- which found that Penn's faculty members are overwhelmingly Democratic by a ratio of 12 to 1 -- surveyed the faculty and administration of 32 colleges and universities around the country. It included all of the Ivy League schools, in addition to other prominent research institutions like Stanford University and smaller colleges such as Amherst and Pomona.
It also documented the commencement speakers and their political leanings from 1994 to 2003 at these same schools.
The study exposed the voting preference of the tenured or tenure-tracked professors in six departments -- Economics, English, History, Philosophy, Political Science and Sociology -- which it claimed "teach courses focusing on issues affecting the society at large."
At Penn, the study determined that of the faculty in these six departments, 60 are registered Democrats, five are registered Republicans and 69 are unaffiliated. According to the study, the political affiliations of 55 professors were undeterminable due to external factors.
Of the University's commencement speakers over the last 10 years, three were labeled as Democrats, five labeled as liberal. Only one, U.S. Senator John McCain, was labeled a Republican, and one, poet Seamus Heaney, was labeled as neutral.
Andrew Jones, who directed the study for the CSPC, said that the center conclusively identified the voter registration of approximately one-third of the professors on campus, and while they would have liked to identify more than half, the ratio likely would not have changed.
"The way I conducted most of these surveys was to use Lexis-Nexis voter database," Jones said. "This is certainly a valid, up-to-date voter database. However, it only searches on a statewide level. If a professor had a generic name, his or her political affiliation could not be determined."
In addition to having a liberal faculty, the study noted, not a single conservative administrator could be identified at Penn.
However, Penn was certainly not the only school identified as leaning liberal. In fact, according to the study, not a single department -- let alone school -- surveyed had as many registered Republicans as Democrats.
Among all 32 schools surveyed, the total number of registered Democrats was 1,397, the number of registered Republicans was 134 and the number of unaffiliated professors was 1,891.
Jones and Horowitz argued the large number of liberal faculty members means that the viewpoints of conservative students never get to be heard.
"The impression that conservative values and ideas aren't welcome on campus is driven home daily to students until it becomes second nature," Horowitz wrote. "Professors generally do not grade politically, but a large enough percentage do that students -- and not just conservative students -- will take the prudent course of concealing what they actually think in order to protect their academic standing."
Political Science Professor Avery Goldstein disagreed with the study's conclusions, however, saying that a professor's political preference should have no effect on the subject matter taught in a class.
The idea, he says, is not to hire or tenure professors based on their political preference, but rather on their academic credentials.
He added that tenured professors do not have to worry about losing their job over their changing viewpoints, and a department cannot predict how a professor will end up leaning politically.
"Like Supreme Court justices, you can't predict how [tenured professors] will change their minds," he said. "You just hope you hire the best and brightest minds."




Comments (3)
Reader
December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm
Flag this comment
Don't make false conclusions. Just because the faculty is overwhelmingly liberal doesn't mean that conservative views are ignored in the classroom (either in teaching of information or evaluation of students' work.) That being said, I am not surprised that the faculty at Penn and other institutions are more liberal than conservative, but I am surprised with the numbers. A good follow-up to this study would be to assess whether or not these political standpoints have an effect on teaching. THEN we could say things like, "The impression that conservative values and ideas aren't welcome on campus is driven home daily to students until it becomes second nature," If this assessment is true, it should be a serious concern. I didn't take many courses from these disciplines, but in the few that I took, my professors tried to conceal their own opinions (not even just political) as much as possible, so that we could form our own. Penn Alum
LYNHMYC
June 26, 2010, 3:04 am
Flag this comment
unreal by sagacious professionals who fathom what wearing a rightful advocate subjection discharge to your image, you culpability never header hateful hide them. over the best deals of Omega Speedmaster equivalent watches, swissmirrorwatch.com entrust guarantee you that. You wont buy how dejected yo
xianming2009
June 28, 2010, 5:56 am
Flag this comment
leave school; for-profit colleges make sure that even students who can't pay fill out deferment or forbearance forms to keep the numbers in line. After that, the former students are on their own, and things get worse fast. Eisman estimates the default rate after three years at Corinthian Colleges, a 105,000-student for-profit school group, at a startling 41 percent.
Comments are closed for this item.