South Street Bridge prompts spot inspections

The span was closed last Thursday due to falling concrete

· June 12, 2003, 5:00 am

Share This

The South Street Bridge dropped pieces of concrete on motorists below last Thursday. The 80-year-old bridge is scheduled for reconstruction. [Daniel McQuade/The Summer Pennsylvanian]


After a chunk of concrete fell from the South Street Bridge late last week, the city has initiated random inspections of about ten bridges "of the same general type... and of the same general age" as the 80 year-old bridge according to Philadelphia's Chief Engineer and Surveyor Joe Syrnick.

Police closed the bridge at around 4 p.m. Thursday evening due to concrete falling onto Interstate 76 from the structure's sidewalk . Both westbound lanes of the Schuylkill Expressway were also blocked off.

Obligated by federal law to inspect the 350 bridges in its care every two years, the city chose to double-check those bridges similar to the South Street Bridge with inspections over the past three days.

The South Street Bridge itself is scheduled for reconstruction, though Syrnick said work on the project "probably won't start for another four or five years."

"This is by far the most complicated bridge project we've ever done, and by far the most expensive one we've ever done," Syrnick said, noting that the revitalization of the span could run into the $60 million range.

Syrnick explained that, between the sections over freight and passenger rail lines, the river and 76, the South Street Bridge is in fact "quite a series of bridges, all of which are going to be replaced."

Damage to the structure on Thursday was relatively minor -- "a hole... about the size of a cantaloupe" in the sidewalk, according to Syrnick. "We decided at that point that we should remove the whole bay, from the bracing to the bracing, just to be safe," he said.

City workers at the scene removed weak concrete around the hole, creating roughly a two foot by two foot gap which has been plated over. According to Syrnick, the concrete will likely be replaced some time in the next month.

"The roadway is fine, the entire bridge is fine, there was never any structural problem with the bridge in terms of the bridge falling down," Syrnick added. "In spite of what we all think, this sort of thing happens, it wasn't like, 'Oh my gosh, we'd never seen this kind of thing before.'"

Syrnick attributed the incident to "a combination of being very old... having a bad winter... and the recent intense wetness."

The University has been heavily involved in the planning of the reconstruction. Special attention has been paid to access to the Hollenback Center, home to Penn's Naval Reserve Officers Training Corps program.

The new bridge will also feature broadened sidewalks, creating a "promenade" over the river.

Comments (1)

Reader

December 31, 1969, 7:00 pm

Flag this comment

The new design of the South Street Bridge is an extremely important design opportunity for U of Penn, for Drexel and for Philadelphia. The University President, EVP and Dean of Design must select a leader to make sure that the design is one that represents the highest dreams of innovation and highest standard of bridges that connect neighborhoods and that embraces the crossing of our city's most intimate downtown river. This is an opportunity to design and to build a bridge that will attract people to come to see it as an achievement, as a monument to intelligently and beautifully solving a very complicated engineering, architectural and artistic problem. The two most recent bridges built in Philadelphia without such wise and inspired leadership are very sad to see and one, so far, is very dangerous to use. The dangerous one is the Walnut Street Speedway Bridge connecting West Philadelphia with Center City. Penn DOT takes great pride in the Walnut Street Speedway. The other one is nearing completition in Chestnut Hill. It is the new Highway Massive Girder Thing built crushingly brutally over the Wissahickon Creek. This bridge has all of the design sensibility of thick plastic slipcovers over much beloved family furniture. Take a look at the fake stone work on the buttresses so thoughtfully designed to look like one's leg suffering from elephantiasis! In fact, it is well worth a trip to see this brutal mess to fully understand the need to reverse this trend and to design our next bridge with the highest level of intelligence that we are capable of achieving. Penn absolutely must prevail and must take the leadership role away from anyone in Penn DOT, Phila Street Dept. and Phila. Bridge Dept who says they know what they are doing. These two bridges show otherwise and will continue to demonstrate diminutive thinking for as long as they stand. We must do better and we can. The South Street Bridge is our third chance to do our best but this can not happen without new passionate and aggressive leadership leading this intriguing design challenge from the beginning. Gardner A. Cadwalader, Architect/Financial Adviser Philadelphia gardnercad@aol.com

Comments are closed for this item.